Top 3 promising IP business models in China — and the patent pool is not among them

From Shanghai to the World

Last month an announcement attracted much attention among the global IP professionals. An international patent portfolio had settled in Shanghai.  According to the source, it is the first of its kind in China.[1]

 
The announcement indicates that this patent pool covers more than 50 technical fields and has an international patent portfolio with more than 12,000 patents. It targets Chinese SMEs which need to upgrade their operation with more advanced technologies but fall short of developing their own.

The pool will operate with standardized licensing terms.  Available licensing durations are one year, three years, five years, and ten years.

Will They Succeed?

A Non-Practicing Entity (NPE) is a well-established business model in the US.  However, the potential of such a business model seems limited in China for two reasons from the analysis of Innovation’s Crouching Tiger (www.ictiger2020.com). 

First, Chinese culture tends to favor harmony over confrontation. The business community does not entirely embrace the idea of the western adversary judicial system, and this business model relies on litigation and effective enforcement.

Second, Chinese courts have been acting in line with a global trend that becomes less friendly to NPEs, as exemplified in the America Invents Act (AIA) enacted in the US in 2011.

The Blossoming of New IP Business Models

However, no matter whether this new project in Shanghai succeeds or not, similar ventures will continue.

In China, the interest in exploring IP business opportunities was stimulated by the successful global stories, including Getty Museum, Intellectual Ventures, and international research institutions, such as MIT.  They all operate profitable models based on IP monetization.

This interest group was small at the beginning. However, in the past few years, thanks to the government policy and the long-tail effect of prevalent social media, the discussions, debates, and experiments of new IP business models have arrived at a new level.  The heat has even gone beyond this professional circle to attract the larger business community.

As China’s IP regime develops, more proven business models originated from developed countries are now starting to flourish in China. For example, numerous projects of IP securitization, IP brokerages, and patent-based public stock indexes have been gaining their business volumes.

The Most Promising New Models

In 2019, SpringIP Group – a company dedicated to enterprise innovation through AI and big data – published a survey about this phenomenon.  Using a framework from previous researchers[2], SpringIP applied its proprietary methodology to the information and opinions collected in the US and China.

In conclusion, SpringIP Group identified the top four most promising IP business models in China for the next ten years.  As summarized in the following table, the top four most promising models are：

#1    IP/Technology Development Companies
#2    IP-Backed Financiers
#3    University Technology Transfer Intermediaries
#4    Technology/IP Spinout Financing

Interested in the methodology of this survey and how to use it to develop a viable IP business model in China?  See more insights by visiting our blog at ICTiger2020.com or Facebook at ICTiger2020 for related news updates.  Contact author at Jili_ICT@springip.com. 

IP Business Opportunities in China (2019) —— Surveyed by SpringIP Group (智汇权科技)

[1]http://www.chinaipmagazine.com/en/news-show.asp?id=12018
[2]See the framework in, A Summary of Established & Emerging IP Business Models, by Raymond Millien PCT Capital LLC and Ron Laurie Inflexion Point Strategy LLC – 2008.

Source：iprdaily.com

Author：Jili Chung

Editor：IPRdaily-Vapor